Tim Castelli, VP of Global Advertising Sales at Instacart
Mon Feb 02 2026
Tim Castelli has built a career by repeatedly stepping away from what was comfortable in order to lean into what was coming next. From print to digital, from static to dynamic, and from content to commerce, he never sits still.
Tim joins the podcast to talk about growing up as a studious kid in Weirton, West Virginia, what studying psychology at Duke taught him about sales and leadership, and why he believes the most important career moves often require going sideways or backwards in the short term. He reflects on his early years in print at Ziff Davis and Rolling Stone, his decision to leave publishing to get his “MBA in digital” at Google, and what it has been like learning entirely new languages like search, digital audio and retail media.
Jordan and Tim also discuss his appreciation for "things that are true, but hard to understand," his mom's ultimatum back when he was still living at home, and how he had Pittsburgh Steelers royalty gathered at his kitchen table as a kid. He also goes on the record (sort of) by naming the best agency relationship leader he has ever worked with.
More
Tim Castelli has built a career by repeatedly stepping away from what was comfortable in order to lean into what was coming next. From print to digital, from static to dynamic, and from content to commerce, he never sits still. Tim joins the podcast to talk about growing up as a studious kid in Weirton, West Virginia, what studying psychology at Duke taught him about sales and leadership, and why he believes the most important career moves often require going sideways or backwards in the short term. He reflects on his early years in print at Ziff Davis and Rolling Stone, his decision to leave publishing to get his “MBA in digital” at Google, and what it has been like learning entirely new languages like search, digital audio and retail media. Jordan and Tim also discuss his appreciation for "things that are true, but hard to understand," his mom's ultimatum back when he was still living at home, and how he had Pittsburgh Steelers royalty gathered at his kitchen table as a kid. He also goes on the record (sort of) by naming the best agency relationship leader he has ever worked with.