No One Wants To Read Your Real Estate Newsletter in 2026
Fri Feb 06 2026
If you’re a real estate agent still sending the monthly email newsletter, market update + “5 tips” + new listings + a recipe + a meme, I’m going to say the quiet part out loud:
That’s not relationship-building. That’s broadcasting into the void.
And the worst part? You might think it’s “working” because your open rates look decent… but open rates are a broken ruler now. Privacy features can inflate opens without a human ever reading a word.
So if you’ve been using opens as your win… I hate to be the one to tell you this… but that metric is lying to your face.
In this episode, we’re talking about what actually indicates intent in real estate marketing (hint: it’s clicks), why newsletter-style emails underperform, and the biggest reason they fail: they’re built like content, not communication.
You’ll also see why the classic “one email for everyone” strategy creates the most watered-down, middle-of-the-road message possible, meaning it’s relevant to basically no one.
Past clients. Cold leads. Future buyers. Window shoppers. Upsizers. Downsizers. First-time buyers. Everyone gets the same “newspaper email”… and then agents wonder why nothing converts.
And yes, I’ll walk you through a real newsletter I got this week and show you exactly how the clicks die with every extra step.
If you want email marketing that actually drives appointments and listings in 2026, you need to stop treating your email list like a bulletin board and start treating it like a system.
Do you have questions about The Listings Lab or our 7-Figure Agent programs and want to see if we'd be a good fit? Click the link below to book a FREE 15-minute discovery call to chat about your business and how we can help. https://www.thelistingslab.com/apply/
More
If you’re a real estate agent still sending the monthly email newsletter, market update + “5 tips” + new listings + a recipe + a meme, I’m going to say the quiet part out loud: That’s not relationship-building. That’s broadcasting into the void. And the worst part? You might think it’s “working” because your open rates look decent… but open rates are a broken ruler now. Privacy features can inflate opens without a human ever reading a word. So if you’ve been using opens as your win… I hate to be the one to tell you this… but that metric is lying to your face. In this episode, we’re talking about what actually indicates intent in real estate marketing (hint: it’s clicks), why newsletter-style emails underperform, and the biggest reason they fail: they’re built like content, not communication. You’ll also see why the classic “one email for everyone” strategy creates the most watered-down, middle-of-the-road message possible, meaning it’s relevant to basically no one. Past clients. Cold leads. Future buyers. Window shoppers. Upsizers. Downsizers. First-time buyers. Everyone gets the same “newspaper email”… and then agents wonder why nothing converts. And yes, I’ll walk you through a real newsletter I got this week and show you exactly how the clicks die with every extra step. If you want email marketing that actually drives appointments and listings in 2026, you need to stop treating your email list like a bulletin board and start treating it like a system. Do you have questions about The Listings Lab or our 7-Figure Agent programs and want to see if we'd be a good fit? Click the link below to book a FREE 15-minute discovery call to chat about your business and how we can help. https://www.thelistingslab.com/apply/