How NOT to Build Your College List
Mon Feb 02 2026
Building a college list can feel overwhelming—and it's easy to get it wrong. In this episode of The College Prep Podcast, Megan and Erin break down the most common mistakes students and families make when creating a college list and explain how to avoid last-minute stress and disappointment.
Rather than focusing on the "perfect" way to build a list, the hosts walk through how not to do it. They discuss why waiting until senior year is a recipe for panic, why rankings and prestige don't tell you whether a school is actually a good fit, and how ignoring financial realities can derail the process later. Megan and Erin also unpack risky strategies like applying to only one or two schools, choosing colleges for superficial reasons or location alone, and basing an entire list on a prospective major—even though many students change majors once they're enrolled.
The conversation also tackles relationship-driven decisions, such as following friends or romantic partners to college, and why those choices so often lead to regret. Along the way, the hosts share real stories from their work with students and families to illustrate what can go wrong when the college list isn't built thoughtfully.
This episode is a must-listen for parents and students who want to start the college search earlier, make realistic and informed choices, and build a balanced list that reflects fit, finances, and flexibility—not panic or prestige.
Questions?
If you have questions, feedback, or ideas for an upcomming show, we'd love to hear from you. You can email us at collegepreppodcast (at) gmail (dot) com
More about the hosts
Megan Dorsey is a parent, educator, and SAT/ACT prep expert. She graduated from Rice University and has over 25 years of experience helping students earn better scores and put together strong applications. Megan lives in Sugar Land, Texas and works with students in-person and on Zoom. You can find out more at CollegePrepResults.com.
Erin Tempest is the founder of Seattle Success Coaching where she and her team help families with a wide range of issues. Let Erin take the frustration out of learning with her academic support, exectuvie function coaching, and social/life skills packages. Her goal is to help parents get back to enjoying their kids. You can find out more at SeattleSuccessCoaching.com.
More
Building a college list can feel overwhelming—and it's easy to get it wrong. In this episode of The College Prep Podcast, Megan and Erin break down the most common mistakes students and families make when creating a college list and explain how to avoid last-minute stress and disappointment. Rather than focusing on the "perfect" way to build a list, the hosts walk through how not to do it. They discuss why waiting until senior year is a recipe for panic, why rankings and prestige don't tell you whether a school is actually a good fit, and how ignoring financial realities can derail the process later. Megan and Erin also unpack risky strategies like applying to only one or two schools, choosing colleges for superficial reasons or location alone, and basing an entire list on a prospective major—even though many students change majors once they're enrolled. The conversation also tackles relationship-driven decisions, such as following friends or romantic partners to college, and why those choices so often lead to regret. Along the way, the hosts share real stories from their work with students and families to illustrate what can go wrong when the college list isn't built thoughtfully. This episode is a must-listen for parents and students who want to start the college search earlier, make realistic and informed choices, and build a balanced list that reflects fit, finances, and flexibility—not panic or prestige. Questions? If you have questions, feedback, or ideas for an upcomming show, we'd love to hear from you. You can email us at collegepreppodcast (at) gmail (dot) com More about the hosts Megan Dorsey is a parent, educator, and SAT/ACT prep expert. She graduated from Rice University and has over 25 years of experience helping students earn better scores and put together strong applications. Megan lives in Sugar Land, Texas and works with students in-person and on Zoom. You can find out more at CollegePrepResults.com. Erin Tempest is the founder of Seattle Success Coaching where she and her team help families with a wide range of issues. Let Erin take the frustration out of learning with her academic support, exectuvie function coaching, and social/life skills packages. Her goal is to help parents get back to enjoying their kids. You can find out more at SeattleSuccessCoaching.com.