High Cortisol, Low Progesterone: Why Your Body Chooses Survival (and How to Feel Safe Again)
Tue Feb 03 2026
When your hormones feel "off," it's easy to assume you need a new supplement… but what if your body is simply doing its job?
In this episode of Fresh & Fired Up, Dr. Emily Marshall and Hailee Piendl break down the hormonal hierarchy—why your body will always prioritize survival hormones (cortisol) over reproductive hormones (progesterone), and how chronic stress can quietly lead to low progesterone, cycle disruption, and that "wired but tired" feeling.
You'll learn why oxytocin isn't just the "bonding hormone"—it can be a powerful buffer against stress when life feels demanding, and why real recovery comes from creating nervous system safety, not just stacking more protocols.
Inside, we cover:
Why cortisol gets produced first (and what that means for progesterone) The cortisol–progesterone connection and chronic stress patterns How oxytocin brings relief, hope, and regulation in high-stress seasons Why you can't supplement your way out of chronically high cortisol Simple micro-habits that help your body feel safe again How understanding your cycle + workload can reduce hormone chaos The role of self-awareness and boundaries in hormonal balance Why progress takes time—and how to be patient with your body If you're working hard, carrying a lot, and trying to "fix" hormones with more effort—this one will help you zoom out, calm down, and rebuild from the foundation.
Listen now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube.
More
When your hormones feel "off," it's easy to assume you need a new supplement… but what if your body is simply doing its job? In this episode of Fresh & Fired Up, Dr. Emily Marshall and Hailee Piendl break down the hormonal hierarchy—why your body will always prioritize survival hormones (cortisol) over reproductive hormones (progesterone), and how chronic stress can quietly lead to low progesterone, cycle disruption, and that "wired but tired" feeling. You'll learn why oxytocin isn't just the "bonding hormone"—it can be a powerful buffer against stress when life feels demanding, and why real recovery comes from creating nervous system safety, not just stacking more protocols. Inside, we cover: Why cortisol gets produced first (and what that means for progesterone) The cortisol–progesterone connection and chronic stress patterns How oxytocin brings relief, hope, and regulation in high-stress seasons Why you can't supplement your way out of chronically high cortisol Simple micro-habits that help your body feel safe again How understanding your cycle + workload can reduce hormone chaos The role of self-awareness and boundaries in hormonal balance Why progress takes time—and how to be patient with your body If you're working hard, carrying a lot, and trying to "fix" hormones with more effort—this one will help you zoom out, calm down, and rebuild from the foundation. Listen now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube.